Hello dear
Welcome to Ian’s Pizza Madison Garver Feed Mill
At Ian’s Pizza Madison Garver Feed Mill, the story unfolds in a vibrant, welcoming space where creativity meets flavor. Nestled within the historic Garver Mill, this gem is known for its eclectic pizza offerings, featuring unique combinations like the beloved Mac n’ Cheese and the savory Buffalo Chicken. Each slice showcases fresh ingredients, reflecting a commitment to quality. Diners can enjoy the laid-back atmosphere, complete with both indoor and outdoor seating, making it the perfect place for families and friends. With friendly staff and a community vibe, Ian's Pizza invites guests to explore diverse flavors and experience a delightful culinary adventure.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Cheese or Pepperoni
Dressings
Super Premium Toppings
Southwest
About
Ian’s Pizza Madison Garver Feed Mill
If you're searching for a vibrant spot to grab a slice in Madison, look no further than Ian’s Pizza Madison at Garver Feed Mill. Nestled in the historic Garver complex at 3241 Garver Green, this unique pizza destination combines delicious food with an inviting atmosphere, making it a must-visit local gem.
One of the highlights of Ian’s Pizza is their extensive selection of specialty pizzas available by the slice. For just $4.50, you can enjoy classic cheese or pepperoni, or opt for one of the delightful specialty slices for $5.50. Popular choices include the rich and savory The Shmo, featuring marinara, mozzarella, sausage, grilled onions, and button mushrooms, as well as the intriguing blue cheese and buffalo chicken combo. This makes it easy to sample various flavors during your visit, allowing for a fun and satisfying culinary adventure.
The location itself enhances the dining experience. With both indoor and outdoor seating options, diners can enjoy a wonderful view while indulging in mouthwatering slices. Many patrons have praised the warm and welcoming energy from the staff, with mentions of employees like Emma and Tyler elevating the overall experience through their friendly service.
But the joy doesn’t stop at pizza! Ian’s offers a range of side salads and delectable extras, such as their mixed greens house salad and fan-favorite breadsticks. Pair your meal with some local ice cream or catch a board game at the adjoining shops to make your outing even more enjoyable.
Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or planning a leisurely meal, Ian’s Pizza Madison at Garver Feed Mill delivers an unforgettable experience marked by excellent service and outstanding food. Join the community that has fallen in love with the diverse flavor combinations and positive ambiance. Trust me, once you try it, you'll be eager to return!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ By the slice pizza was great. Nice selection of houseplants throughout the place that you can purchase and take home adds to the atmosphere. ”
“ Huge shoutout to Emma and Tyler—these two absolutely made my visit! Super friendly, welcoming, and on top of everything. The pizza was incredible, but honestly, it was their energy and service that stood out the most. ”
“ First time tried Ian’s pizza and absolutely loved it. Love the vibe of the place and I liked that they had both indoor and outdoor seating at the Garver Mill location. There were so many unique flavor combinations of the pizzas. I like that you can order pizza by slice so you can try different kinds. I enjoyed the Mac n cheese, Penne Alfredo, and All the Veg. Each one of them were so good. Will be back here again to try the other combinations if pizzas. The service was top notch!!! ”
“ Delicious spot! My niece’s favorite spot to get pizza. Love all of the fun flavors. The Mac and cheese is my favorite. I also enjoyed the salads (Farr our is my favorite). The breadsticks are a must too! Seating inside and outside! There is also a board game shop, ice cream, coffee shop, and glitter which is a craft store all within garver. They also hold the farmer’s market here in the winter. Great location! ”
“ Ian's pizza by the slice is very good. Visited the new location in the Garver complex. Pizza's have eclectic toppings and flavors. Blue cheese and buffalo chicken is what I had today. Staff is always friendly and service is great. New location is inviting and wide open. ”
“ If you like thin crust pizza, this is the one. Delicious! They also serve Coke products which is a major plus for me. My only complaint is that they're seating is extremely hard. I'm not sure that this isn't by design to keep people moving though. Highly recommended. ”
“ My wife and I have tried almost every pizza place in Madison and we love Ian's. We hadn't been in a while and we decided to write a review about how great it was the other day it was when we had delivery. Ian's across-the-board is one of the best pizzas for the price and taste that you can get. Of course this is my opinion people like different kinds of pizza. Some people like deep dish some people like New York style excetera excetera. I would compare Ian's to New York style pizza. It's very thin and very large pieces. It's the kind of pizza that you can fold in half. If you know what I'm talking about then that's all you need to know. We love their 20in cheese pizza. The slices are huge, like out of a cartoon. It can easily feed a family of four, no problem. The cheese blend they use is incredible. It's stretchy and slightly salty and wonderful. It goes great on every pizza. Their red sauce isn't overly sweet or too spicy. It's a perfect balance in the middle that appeals to everyone. Their crust is my wife's favorite part. It's not cracker thin, more like new York style that's thin enough to fold while you eat and the end pieces are chewy and yummy. You can even buy the dough to make your own pizza at home, which is a great deal! My wife absolutely loves their Buffalo chicken pizza. It's spicy and yummy and sprinkled with creamy bites of blue cheese that cools the heat. One of our favorite parts of Ian's is that in the restaurant you can buy pizza by the slice. This is great for a few reasons. First, their slices are huge so you only need one or two to fill up anyway. Second, they have so many different types of pizza (like mac and cheese or loaded potato) that would be great to try, but you might not want to order a whole pizza in case it's not your favorite. It allows you to try out some new flavors without committing to a whole pizza. We also love their breadsticks. Their made from the same dough as the crust so they're thick and chewy, dusted with parmesan and Italian seasoning. They're massive as well so it's a great deal to order for a large crowd. We love Ian's and order it everytime we have company since it feeds a crowd and it's a huge crowd pleaser. ”
“ One of the best pizza places I have tried. Love their creativity with all the toppings. I love the system where you select your pizza, go pay and go around to the back to pick up your pizza, where they have free drinks for you to choose from as well. Pretty quick and filling meal and feels a bit healthier than usual franchise pizza places. Tha salad bar looks amazing. Will try next time. ”